|
Back
11/17/2026 Sergei Prokofiev: Chout, opus 21 [1] – Symphony n° 1 in D major “Classical”, opus 25 [2] Adrian Iliescu [1], Daniel Cho [2] (concertmasters), NDR Radiophilharmonie, Stanislav Kochanovksy (conductor)
Recording: Grosse Sendesaal, NDR Konzerthaus, Hanover, Germany (June [2] & November [1] 2025) – 68’43
harmonia mundi HMM 905406 (Distributed by [Integral]) – Booklet in French, English and German


In 1914 Sergei Prokofiev traveled to Paris for the first time to meet Ballets Russes impresario Sergei Diaghilev and pitch his ballet Ala I Lolli. Diaghilev passed on it, thinking it “primitive” and similar to Stravinsky’s Sacre du printemps which had its scandalous premiere the previous season. But Diaghilev did book Prokofiev the following year to perform his Piano Concerto n° 2 in Milan.
Meanwhile, Stravinsky was also in Paris and showed Prokofiev some Russian folk tales by Alexander Afanasyev, including The Story of the Buffoon Who Outwits Seven Others which Prokofiev turned into his ‘savage farce’, Chout, a broad Russian term for jester, trickster, buffoons. Diaghilev eventually staged it in 1921.
Meanwhile, Prokofiev’s career took off in The United States with the premiere of The Love for Three Oranges, commissioned by the Chicago Opera Association in 1918. The Ballets Russes’ premiere was a hit in Paris but a failure with critics and audiences in London that same year. Chout never received the attention that the composer’s other ballets experienced, especially his timeless classic, Romeo and Juliet, one of the most recognized ballet scores of the 20th Century.
Chout is a music-hall ballet with an entr’acte stitching together the tableaux of “The Buffoon and His Wife”, “The Seven Buffoons”, “The Buffoon’s Courtyard”, “The Buffoons’ Sitting Room”, “The Merchant’s Bedroom” and “The Merchant’s Garden”. This ballet farce about murdered wives evidently proved too dark that it was only staged once in Russia and in Ukraine under another title.
But Prokofiev adapted it as an Orchestral Suite (Opus 21 bis), while the full score has been occasionally programed with major orchestras. Forgetting the narrative, the full score is not only dynamic, but prescient with compositional signatures in Prokofiev’s canon.
To Diaghilev’s initial point, Chout contains mystic qualities of the Stravinskian era, with vaporous echoes of Petrushka and Le Sacre du printemps with concussive symphonics and, perhaps, hinting at parody. Meanwhile, the otherwise lithe woodwinds whirl away suggesting masked diabolique.
Triumphal fanfares are ripe for Chout’s dark farcical conceit, but surface with moments of unmasked diabolique. The orchestral exposition is upstaged, for instance, by voicing of snaking oboe solos while up against a wall of carnivalesque fanfare and rollicking orchestral surges. All the orchestral lustiness and subtleties are woven together with “melodic intervals and rhythms of Russian folk song, albeit laced with chromaticisms”, “...Prokofiev’s language is in its free‑and‑easy blend of diatonicism with the extreme borders of tonality, even with frequent incursions of polytonality”, as cited by André Lischke in the booklet commentary.
Its conceits suggest music hall ballet noir, but it is one of Prokofiev’s most provocative scores and so distinct from Prokofiev’s more famous works. Yet it’s equally revelatory in its sagacious agency of coded musicology. By now, its cryptic sensibility foreshadows Prokofiev’s music after he and his family returned to Russia where he was forced to compose under the watch of Stalin’s music censor watchdogs who then silenced the composer’s music, branding it too offensive and innovative with subjective hints of “Western”, aka “anti‑Soviet Russia.”
Prokofiev’s orchestral bravery aimed at the proletariat masses, but his musicality draped around triumphal, nationalistic symphonic themes, most famously eluding the censors in his scores for Sergei Eisenstein’s classic films, Alexander Nevsky and Ivan the Terrible.
Conductor Stanislav Kochanovsky leads a stellar performance of Chout by the 70‑piece NDR Radiophilharmonie. The orchestra ignites this dynamic score with its snarky, satirical musicality. There’s so much “dance drive” in Chout that draws a modernist choreographer to its vaunting lyricism and sardonic edges.
Prokofiev’s musical farce blooms with a splash of warm orchestral colors during “Le Bouffon et sa Bouffonne” (“The Buffoon and His Wife”) (Andantino scherzando). The musical buffoonery enters mid‑way through as well as the vampy murderous plots unfolding in six musical tableaux with interludes anchoring an altogether driving ballet score.
It’s surprising Chout wasn’t staged more frequently: one can guess that it’s ultimately due to the fusionist score and ghoulish narrative. Perhaps the farce is too raw (or too subtle) to be fully appreciated on the ballet stage of its era, but as NDR Radiophilharmonie proves, Prokofiev’s orchestral score is a thriller of its own.
For this recording, conductor Kochanovsky also programmed Prokofiev’s Symphony n° 1, exemplary of Prokofiev’s affinity to classic form. For the NDR Radiophilharmonie this œuvre is a virtuosic breather next to the musical skullduggery of Chout. The second NDR Radiophilharmonie orchestra upstages itself following the controversial and engaging Chout, but this orchestra does just that with its radiant performance of Prokofiev’s debut symphony, styled after Haydn and Mozart and self‑dubbed as “Classical” by Prokofiev, who conducted its premiere.
Lewis J. Whittington
|