About us / Contact

The Classical Music Network

Montreal

Europe : Paris, Londn, Zurich, Geneva, Strasbourg, Bruxelles, Gent
America : New York, San Francisco, Montreal                       WORLD


Newsletter
Your email :

 

Back

Auber and Grandval: Historical Curiosities, Musical Pleasures

Montreal
Maison Symphonique, Place des Arts
11/15/2026 -  
Daniel-François-Esprit Auber: Manon Lescaut (arias)
Jules Massenet: Manon (arias)
Clémence de Grandval: Symphonic pages from operas
Piotr Tchaikovsky: Francesca da Rimini, Op.. 32
Richard Wagner: Tristan und Isolde: Prelude and Liebestod

Sarah Dufresne (soprano)
Orchestre Métropolitain, Keri-Lynn Wilson (conductor)


S. Dufresne, K.-L. Wilson (© François Goupil)


The programme, entitled Héroïnes et passions lyriques, offered audiences an opportunity to discover two composers whose names have largely receded from contemporary concert life, Daniel-François-Esprit Auber (1782‑1871) and Clémence de Grandval (1828‑1907). Both were figures of considerable historical interest, their respective careers illuminating aspects of nineteenth-century French musical culture that are now seldom explored. Their music, however, proved of more moderate interest. The afternoon’s more substantial rewards came from the remarkable vocal accomplishment of soprano Sarah Dufresne and, above all, the two orchestral masterpieces that concluded the programme.


Auber was, in his day, one of the undisputed stars of the Parisian operatic firmament. Following the earlier triumphs of François-Adrien Boieldieu (1775‑1834) and André Grétry (1741‑1813), he became one of the principal architects of French opéra‑comique. His musical language inherited much from these predecessors, while absorbing the influence of Mozart and, increasingly, the melodic conventions of Italian bel canto. His Manon Lescaut (1856), in particular, contains melodic turns that might readily be mistaken for Donizetti. Originality was not necessarily Auber’s strongest suit; theatrical effectiveness and an unfailing gift for melody were.


His prolific output included several works that became international successes: La Muette de Portici, ou Masaniello (1828), Fra Diavolo (1830), Gustave III, ou Le Bal masque (1833), Le Cheval de bronze (1835), Le Domino noir (1837) and Les Diamants de la couronne (1841). His La Muette de Portici even acquired an importance extending well beyond the theatre. Following a performance in Brussels in August 1830, revolutionary demonstrations erupted, contributing to the Belgian revolt against Dutch rule and, ultimately, independence. Few composers have had the distinction of seeing their theatrical creations become entangled so directly with the political history of a nation.


Auber’s Manon Lescaut, with a libretto by Eugène Scribe, was premiered at the Opéra‑Comique in 1856. Its subject, drawn from the Abbé Prévost’s celebrated novel Histoire du chevalier Des Grieux et de Manon Lescaut (1731), was to establish itself as an inexhaustible source of artistic inspiration. The novel’s psychologically complex heroine would subsequently inspire two far more celebrated operatic treatments, by Massenet (1884) and Puccini (1893), as well as numerous cinematic adaptations. Auber’s dramatic conception is, by comparison, considerably less compelling. His Manon is a young woman of modest origins, whose susceptibility to luxury and temptation is presented within the rather prudish moral framework of the Second Empire.


Two years ago, Turin’s Teatro Regio presented all three operatic treatments as a trilogy, an undertaking that afforded an unusually illuminating opportunity for comparison. Having attended Turin’s productions of Puccini and Auber, I came away with little doubt that the latter, notwithstanding its historical interest, was substantially weaker than its two more celebrated successors.


The arias selected for this concert had the advantage of distilling the essential differences between the two French conceptions of Manon. Auber’s heroine is considerably more naïve, almost childlike, her capriciousness still largely untroubled by the tragic consequences of her choices. His celebrated “C’est l’histoire amoureuse”, with its sparkling Eclat de rire cabaletta, was once a favourite vehicle for coloratura sopranos. Sarah Dufresne dispatched its stratospheric excursions with admirable aplomb, negotiating the vocal acrobatics without sacrificing the character’s youthful vivacity. Equally successful was the other selection from Auber, “Plus de rêve qui m’enivre”, in which she conveyed a distinctly different Manon from the more sophisticated and emotionally complex creature encountered in Massenet.


The Canadian soprano has already established a noteworthy presence on the international operatic scene. Having heard her as Ophélie in Ambroise Thomas’s Hamlet in Montréal in 2024 and as Semele in Richard Strauss’s Die Liebe der Danae in Munich in 2025, I have followed her progress with particular interest. Her appearances at the Bayerische Staatsoper and the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, testify to the growing recognition she has earned beyond her native Canada. It is a pleasure to witness the development of a promising artist at this stage of her career, although four arias in a concert so heavily advertised around her presence seemed rather miserly. The many voice lovers who attended expressly to hear her might reasonably have expected a more generous allocation.


Dufresne possesses a bright, clear lyric soprano, with precisely the timbral qualities required for the fragile, somewhat elusive heroines of the French repertoire. Her interpretation of Manon was distinguished not merely by technical accomplishment but by a genuine capacity for characterisation. She conveyed the heroine’s fragility, capriciousness and underlying sadness with considerable sensitivity. Her mastery of coloratura was impressive, but it was her ability to give personality to the vocal writing that proved more consequential. On two occasions, the initial attack of a phrase sounded fractionally sharp, a tendency I had also noticed in her earlier portrayal of Ophélie. The voice quickly settled as it warmed up, and the matter was hardly consequential in the overall impression. One hopes that this minor technical irregularity will soon be entirely overcome.


Graceful, charismatic and endowed with an admirable command of vocal acrobatics, Dufresne possesses the essential attributes of a singer whose career merits close attention. Her artistry is already considerably more than a promising collection of vocal accomplishments; there is an emerging interpretative personality here, and one looks forward to hearing her in increasingly demanding repertoire.


The second neglected figure on the programme was Clémence de Grandval, a French composer whose career offers a particularly interesting illustration of the obstacles confronting women in the nineteenth-century musical establishment. Born into an aristocratic family as Clémence de Reiset, she received an unusually privileged musical education. She studied piano with Chopin and subsequently pursued composition with Camille Saint‑Saëns, who became both a friend and an important advocate of her music. Her operatic output included Le Sou de Lise, Les Fiancés de Rosa, La Comtesse Eva, Piccolino and, later, Mazeppa. She also composed chamber music, orchestral works and sacred music, receiving the Prix Rossini in 1880 for her oratorio La Fille de Jaïre and the Prix Chartier in 1890 for her chamber compositions.


Her social position was, paradoxically, both an advantage and an impediment. As a vicomtesse, she enjoyed access to influential musical circles, yet her aristocratic standing, coupled with the prejudices directed towards women composers, frequently encouraged critics to regard her accomplishments as those of an accomplished amateur rather than a professional musician. Some of her works appeared under pseudonyms. Her subsequent relative disappearance from the repertoire is therefore not entirely a reflection of their intrinsic merits, but also of the historical mechanisms through which musical reputations were established and perpetuated.


The orchestral selections offered a welcome opportunity to encounter a composer whose name is far more familiar to musicologists than to concert audiences. Yet historical rehabilitation should not be confused with aesthetic enthusiasm. Grandval’s music proved agreeable and occasionally attractive, but it did not reveal a particularly distinctive musical personality. Its interest lay principally in the opportunity to encounter a neglected chapter of French Romanticism.


The title Héroïnes et passions lyriques was, moreover, not entirely convincing. While Manon, Francesca and Isolde are undoubtedly heroines of tragic passion, the inclusion of Tristan und Isolde introduces a rather different dramatic universe, in which the male protagonist is every bit as essential to the unfolding of the tragedy. Given the abundance of female protagonists in the operatic and symphonic repertoire, the juxtaposition of Prévost’s Manon with Francesca and Isolde seemed somewhat arbitrary. Nevertheless, the programme’s second half provided a striking contrast to the lighter, more decorative atmosphere of the first.


Keri-Lynn Wilson, whose experience of the operatic repertoire made her a particularly appropriate choice for this programme, presided over the Orchestre Métropolitain with assurance and evident command. The orchestra responded with admirable discipline and flexibility, moving convincingly from the more delicate textures of the French selections to the expansive emotional demands of the two great Romantic orchestral works. Wilson’s conducting combined structural clarity with a keen appreciation of theatrical progression, allowing the music to unfold without sacrificing its dramatic impetus.


Tchaikovsky’s Francesca da Rimini proved a particularly rewarding undertaking. Inspired by the episode of Paolo and Francesca in the fifth canto of Dante’s Inferno, the symphonic fantasia offers one of the composer’s most vivid evocations of literary tragedy. Its opening, with the orchestra conjuring the relentless turbulence of the infernal winds, establishes an atmosphere of almost overwhelming violence. Against this tumultuous backdrop, the central love episode emerges as an expansive and deeply lyrical interlude, its ardent melodic writing suggesting both the ecstasy and the fatality of the lovers’ passion. Wilson maintained a persuasive balance between the work’s contrasting elements, allowing the central lyricism to bloom without diminishing the menace of its orchestral surroundings. The OM responded with considerable dramatic intensity and a gratifying sense of cohesion.


The concluding Prelude and Liebestod from Wagner’s Tristan und Isolde brought the afternoon to an appropriately exalted close. Few works have explored the relationship between desire, musical tension and transcendence with such extraordinary consistency. The Prelude’s seemingly inexhaustible harmonic yearning, its suspensions and unresolved longings, ultimately finds its apotheosis in Isolde’s final transfiguration. Wilson gave the music the necessary breadth and continuity, while the orchestra sustained the long musical arcs with commendable sensitivity. The Liebestod unfolded with the requisite amplitude, its climactic release providing a fitting culmination to an afternoon devoted, ostensibly, to the many manifestations of tragic passion.


If the first half had sparkled like a glass of champagne, the second offered something altogether more intoxicating: a powerful brew of fatalism, erotic longing and metaphysical yearning. The contrast was considerable, and decidedly welcome.


The afternoon ultimately demonstrated that musical rediscovery is not necessarily synonymous with artistic revelation. Auber and Grandval may have earned their place in the historical record, but neither quite justified a wholesale rehabilitation of the repertoire. Fortunately, the evening’s more illustrious companions, Tchaikovsky and Wagner, required no such advocacy. Under Keri‑Lynn Wilson’s assured direction, the Orchestre Métropolitain rose to the occasion, while Sarah Dufresne offered further evidence of an already impressive artistry, leaving one eager to discover the full extent of her interpretative and vocal possibilities in future encounters. If the first half was an agreeable exercise in musical archaeology, the second reminded us why certain masterpieces have stubbornly resisted the passage of time. Some passions, after all, are more enduring than others.



Ossama el Naggar

 

 

Copyright ©ConcertoNet.com