About us / Contact

The Classical Music Network

Montreal

Europe : Paris, Londn, Zurich, Geneva, Strasbourg, Bruxelles, Gent
America : New York, San Francisco, Montreal                       WORLD


Newsletter
Your email :

 

Back

The Lavender Scare: Love in the Shadow of Betrayal

Montreal
McGill University, Pollack Hall
11/12/2026 -  & November 13, 14, 2026
Gregory Spears: Fellow Travelers
Michael Christopher*/Caden Teliha (Timothy Laughlin), Liam Dooley*/Zachary Kelly (Hawkins Fuller), Alina Tigelman*/Emilie Versailles (Mary Johnson), Patricia Wrigglesworth*/Elizabeth Fast (Miss Lightfoot), AJ Gauger*/Sarah Shoff (Lucy), Matthew Carlson (Tommy McIntyre), Christopher Pitre‑McBride (Senator McCarthy, Estonian Frank), David Nicolle (Senator Potter), Joshua Myers (General Arlie, Bartender, Senator Potter’s Assistant, Party Guest), Vetiver Long (Bookseller, Interrogator), Léo Forest (Priest, Technician, Hotel Bartender), Sarah Shoff*/AJ Gauger (Francie)
Opera McGill, Stephen Hargreaves (conductor)
Patrick Hansen (stage director), Jonathan Monro (intimacy director), Vincent Lefèvre (set designer, projections), Ginette Grenier (costume and makeup designer, Jon Cleveland (lighting designer)


The Red Scare and the Lavender Scare were two manifestations of the same paranoid American political climate, in which ideological conformity and moral respectability became instruments of persecution. While Senator Joseph McCarthy’s anti‑Communist crusade destroyed careers and reputations, a less familiar but equally insidious campaign targeted homosexual men and women employed by the federal government. Under President Eisenhower, Executive Order 10450, signed in 1953, effectively sanctioned their exclusion from government service, on the specious grounds that their supposed moral vulnerability made them susceptible to blackmail. It was against this background of political hysteria, institutionalised homophobia and enforced secrecy that Gregory Spears set Fellow Travelers, an opera whose intimate emotional drama was inextricably bound to the historical circumstances that shaped it.


Based on Thomas Mallon’s 2007 novel, with a libretto by Greg Pierce, the two‑act opera was premiered at Cincinnati Opera in 2016. Its action unfolded in Washington between 1953 and 1957, revolving around the clandestine relationship between Timothy Laughlin, a young, devout Catholic newly arrived in the capital, and Hawkins Fuller, a worldly and considerably older State Department official. Initially attracted to the young man’s idealism and innocence, Hawkins became his lover and helped him obtain a position in the office of Senator Charles Potter. Their liaison, however, had to remain concealed in an environment where professional advancement, personal survival and sexual identity were irreconcilable. As political scrutiny intensified, jealousy, fear and conflicting temperaments progressively undermined their relationship, culminating in a devastating betrayal.


Gregory Spears (born 1977) belonged to a generation of American composers who had sought to reconcile contemporary musical idioms with a more immediately communicative, tonal language. His work drew upon post‑minimalism, particularly its repetitive rhythmic structures and gradual accumulation of instrumental textures, while retaining a pronounced affinity for lyrical vocal writing. In Fellow Travelers, these elements were enriched by references to early music, Romanticism and an occasionally neo‑verismo sensibility. The result was an accessible yet sophisticated score, whose musical vocabulary proved remarkably well suited to the opera’s alternating worlds of bureaucratic anxiety and concealed passion. Its idiom occasionally recalled Samuel Barber in its melodic expansiveness and Stephen Sondheim in its conversational fluency and theatrical acuity.


Having first encountered the opera in Chicago in March 2018, I was particularly pleased to rediscover it in this production by Opera McGill, which offered its Canadian academic premiere. The enthusiasm of the young performers was palpable, as was the engagement of an audience composed largely of students. Such evident commitment lent the evening an infectious freshness, without compromising the seriousness of the subject. Indeed, the performance was a persuasive demonstration of the rewards of introducing young singers to contemporary operatic repertoire rather than confining their experience to the established canon.


Stephen Hargreaves conducted with admirable alertness, maintaining an appropriately nervous momentum that reflected the characters’ precarious existence. He was particularly judicious in the treatment of the more expansive Romantic passages, resisting the temptation to indulge their lyricism at the expense of dramatic continuity. Spears’s score juxtaposed minimalist ostinatos, passages of almost conversational simplicity, early‑music inflections and generous melodic effusions. Despite this apparent disparity of styles, the music never seemed truncated or episodic; rather, it flowed like a carefully woven tapestry, whose diverse threads remained integrated within a remarkably coherent musical fabric.


The minimalist passages were especially effective in reinforcing the pervasive Angst and insecurity of the protagonists. Their repetitive patterns suggested the relentless machinery of bureaucracy and surveillance, while the more lyrical writing opened windows onto emotional landscapes that the characters themselves were unable to articulate. Particularly affecting were Hawkins’s introspective passages, in which the vocal writing assumed an almost archaic, sweetly melismatic character. Spears himself described the lovers’ florid, troubadour‑like melodies as expressions of their passionate inner lives, set against the contrasting musical language of the outside world. This opposition constituted one of the score’s most compelling achievements.


Nevertheless, one reservation remained. Given the gravity of the protagonists’ predicament and the devastating consequences of the Lavender Scare, the music occasionally seemed insufficiently ferocious. One might have wished for greater menace, sharper dissonances and a more visceral orchestral response at the most consequential dramatic junctures, particularly Hawkins’s cowardly betrayal of Timothy. The score’s habitual elegance sometimes appeared to soften the brutality of the circumstances it depicted. Yet this was a limitation of dramatic emphasis rather than of compositional accomplishment.


The young cast was, on the whole, remarkably accomplished, with Liam Dooley as Hawkins emerging as the evening’s outstanding performer. Endowed with considerable magnetism, ample charisma and an appealingly virile voice, he combined vocal assurance with exceptional acting skills. His Hawkins was neither a mere seducer nor a conventional villain, but a complex, attractive and ultimately compromised individual. Dooley invested the character with precisely the mixture of confidence, charm and emotional evasiveness that made his behaviour both comprehensible and disturbing.


Michael Christopher was an excellent actor as Timothy, conveying the young man’s emotional vulnerability and gradual disillusionment with considerable conviction. Vocally, however, he encountered difficulties in the upper register, particularly in several passages demanding sustained high tessitura, where the voice occasionally tightened and lost some of its natural freedom. His theatrical contribution nevertheless remained persuasive.


The supporting cast was particularly strong in its portrayal of characters whose individual shortcomings were integral to the opera’s social panorama. Patricia Wrigglesworth made a striking impression as Miss Lightfoot, the maliciously gossipy secretary. Both scenically and vocally impressive, she negotiated the upper register with ease while giving a wonderfully unsympathetic portrait of a callous woman seemingly devoid of empathy. Her petty officiousness and relish for other people’s misfortunes were rendered with incisive theatrical intelligence.


Alina Tigelman offered a very different kind of presence as Mary Johnson. Warm, generous and almost maternal, she became a genuinely sympathetic figure, a protective confidante whose charisma and affectionate demeanour were matched by an equally warm vocal quality. Her humanity provided a welcome counterweight to the pervasive atmosphere of suspicion and duplicity.


AJ Gauger’s Lucy, Hawkins’s eventual wife, was deliberately presented as a rather insipid personality. This was an entirely appropriate characterisation of a woman who, while not quite a pawn, remained essentially a piece in the chess game of Hawkins’s carefully concealed existence. Her relative lack of substance was less a shortcoming of the performer than a reflection of the character’s deliberately limited dramatic function.


Patrick Hansen’s staging was an altogether persuasive achievement. Its sparseness was dictated in part by the practical constraints of a student production, yet the director transformed this apparent limitation into an aesthetic virtue. The judicious use of colourful projections on the panels lent the otherwise economical sets considerable life and variety, while providing immediate geographical and psychological orientation. The Washington monuments evoked the political establishment; the evocative imagery of New Orleans conjured Mary’s world; the suburban domestic setting of Hawkins’s married life conveyed the respectable façade he sought to maintain; and the red‑brick surroundings of Timothy’s home at the conclusion provided an appropriately poignant visual frame for the opera’s final moments. Nothing appeared gratuitous, and the projections served the drama rather than competing with it. The clarity of the staging was particularly welcome in a work that moved frequently between locations and contrasting emotional states.


The production also benefited from a sensitive understanding of the opera’s central relationship. One of the strengths of both the libretto and Hansen’s interpretation was their refusal to reduce the older, more experienced Hawkins to a predatory monster, while equally avoiding the temptation to portray him merely as a cowardly informer. His final denunciation of Timothy, an act that effectively destroyed the younger man’s career, remained cruel and morally indefensible. Yet one could also believe that Hawkins had persuaded himself that this was, paradoxically, an act of mercy: by making Timothy hate him, he might spare him the more prolonged and dangerous consequences of their attachment. Whether this interpretation was justified or merely another expression of Hawkins’s capacity for self‑deception was deliberately left unresolved.


Such ambiguity was essential to the opera’s emotional credibility. To reduce the relationship to that of a predatory seducer and an innocent victim would have diminished its psychological complexity. Both men were flawed, both were responsible for inflicting pain upon the other, and both were ultimately victims of an epoch that denied them the possibility of living honestly. Their tragedy lay not simply in the failure of their relationship, but in the impossibility of reconciling private affection with the demands of a society governed by fear, hypocrisy and intolerance.


I greatly enjoyed this revival. More than eight years after my first encounter with Fellow Travelers in Chicago, the work retained its emotional immediacy, while this spirited and accomplished student production demonstrated how effectively it could communicate with a new generation. Its occasional reluctance to confront the full musical brutality of its subject notwithstanding, Spears’s opera remained a moving and unusually humane account of love compromised by history. The palpable commitment of the young performers, the intelligence of the musical direction and the thoughtful staging combined to make this a particularly rewarding evening.



Ossama el Naggar

 

 

Copyright ©ConcertoNet.com