|
Back
If you want a full house, make sure to program Beethoven... New York Alice Tully Hall & Daniel and Joanna S. Rose Studio at CMS 10/25/2026 - & November 5*, 6, 2026
Alice Tully Hall, October 25, 2026
Ludwig van Beethoven: Sonatas No.1 in F Minor op.2 No.1, No.21 in C Major “Waldstein”, op.53, & No.29 in B‑flat Major “Hammerklavier”, op.106
Daniel and Joanna S. Rose Studio at CMS, November 5* & 6, 2026
Ludwig van Beethoven: Sonatas No.4 in E‑flat Major, op.7, No.8 in C minor “Pathétique”, op.13, & No.11 in B‑flat Major, op.22
Gilles Vonsattel (piano)
 Pianist Gilles Vonsattel performs the second concert in his 14‑date series with the Chamber Music Society of Lincoln Center, featuring the complete Beethoven piano sonatas. November 5, 2026, at the Daniel and Joanna S. Rose Studio at CMS (© Cherylynn Tsushima)
As the musical world celebrates in 2027 the 200th anniversary of Beethoven’s death, that also means that there will be year‑long celebrations devoted to his music: his sonatas, symphonies, quartets and trios will be performed in complete cycles, often by well‑established or great artists. I tend to believe that the audiences respond to Beethoven’s music regardless of anniversaries: as the saying goes, “give them Beethoven and they’ll come”. Still, it is an illuminating, exciting and edifying experience to have a chance to hear one artist or ensemble tackling the whole set of works, such as piano sonatas or complete string quartets.
Here in New York, we will have several such chances at Carnegie Hall, where the piano legend Martha Argerich, assisted by the famed violinist Maxim Vengerov, will perform in the span of three evenings the complete cycle of sonatas for piano and violin (so‑called “violin sonatas”, what a misnomer!!!). And the great Ebene Quartet will offer us the complete cycle of 16 quartets. In addition, Igor Levit, the formidable Russian‑German pianist, returns to Carnegie Hall with the first half of the 32 piano sonatas. All of the three cycles will take place in the spring of 2027.
But before that happens, in the fall of 2026 and continuing into March of 2027, it is our distinguished Chamber Music Society of Lincoln Center that for the first time in its more than half‑century existence is presenting one pianist performing the complete 32 sonatas. The pianist for that difficult task Gilles Vonsattel, hailing from Switzerland but long an American citizen, for the past two decades tightly connected with CMS as a valued chamber musician. What will make this cycle unusually attractive is the fact that Vonsattel’s recital will be accompanied by his lectures on Beethoven sonatas. (I shall provide the links at the end of this review.)
It is worth noting that the series: two recitals at Alice Tully Hall and six in the Rose Studio were sold out the moment they were announced and extra repeats needed to be added for each of the Rose Studio recitals. Both concerts attended took place in the sold‑out venues (Alice Tully Hall and Rose Studio) and the reception offered to the artist was more than enthusiastic.
In the interview attached in the program booklet, Vonsattel admits that before being asked by the CMS to be the first performer in their history to be asked to present the whole Beethoven cycle, he didn’t have all the sonatas in his repertoire and had spared no effort to learn the fiendishly difficult Sonata No.29 “Hammerklavier”, included in the opening program, alongside the Sonata No.1 and one of the most famous, Sonata “Waldstein” for its dedication to the Count who championed Beethoven when he was still relatively unknown. It was an excellent program illuminating all three major periods in the composer’s creativity and, in a way, demonstrating the best in each. One may, of course, argue that very little among those sonatas could be relegated to the “lower shelf.”
I am always surprised that the first sonata, with which the young composer burst into the aristocrats’ salons without taking off his coat, is so rarely performed outside of the complete series. Even in the early part of his career as composer, his genius for developing the musical form out of minute motifs is already evident. The early Sonata in F minor displays an incredible combination of energy, vitality and humor, yet in its second movement Adagio we hear moments of lyricism and tenderness. There the 25‑year‑old composer is already quoting himself with the material previously used in his youthful Piano Quartet in C major (without opus number). And in the whirlwind finale Prestissimo one can almost foresee the turbulent character of the Appassionata, incidentally also in the key of F Minor.
In the mature “Waldstein” Sonata, Beethoven enters a different realm: here he introduces a new sonata design, in which two large outer movements are bridged by a four-minute-long Introduction, technically in F Major, a replacement for a slow movement. The bubbling repeated notes of the opening Allegro contrast with a second theme in a remote key of E Major. And then we have another novelty, which is the coda in the concluding Rondo: it is based on the opening lyrical theme, for which the French gave this sonata the surname “L’Aurore” (the dawn), except the composer demands that it be played Prestissimo, or as fast as possible. That movement is also known for another short segment, which frequently confuses the performers: there, we see the descending and ascending C Major octave scales, to be played pianissimo. Some pianists feel that those should be played in the conventional manner, while others, including this writer, feel that Beethoven wanted them to be played as glissandos, and that is very difficult on a contemporary instrument, especially if it is supposed to be as soft as the composer required. As I had not seen the keyboard, it sounded to me that Mr Vonsattel chose the more difficult option and it sounded splendid! (A little aside for piano mavens: in that particular “glissando moment,” some great virtuosos of the past [such as Horowitz or his pupil Byron Janis] wanted to show off their “octave proficiency,” which also proved how poorly they knew Beethoven’s writing. The great Claudio Arrau in one of interviews mentioned that while choosing the piano before the recital, he would just try if its keyboard responded to the octave glissandos: if so, no further rehearsal was needed.)
As for the concluding Sonata in B‑flat, op.106, about which, upon its completion in 1818 the composer declared that “it is going to be a nightmare for its performers 50 years from then.” This sonata, and especially its last movement, a ten‑minute fugue, remains as difficult for the pianists as it ever was. The performing difficulties in Op.106 abound, both technically and interpretively including concern the choice of the tempo in the first movement (the nominal Allegro con brio has an insane metronome marking, which simply makes no sense. Did Beethoven really want it as fast? Even on the piano with a much lighter keyboard and much clearer sound?) Then there is the matter of the Adagio, a prolonged, wistful, sometimes ardent slow movement in which the pianist is already confronted with the climate of approaching romanticism, and finally a finger‑twisting fugue, immensely hard to memorize ( if THAT was necessary...).
It should come as no surprise that in Mr. Vonsattel those three sonatas found an excellent interpreter: first‑rate pianist, with impeccable pianistic skills, an intelligent and searching musician with the utmost regard for the score. His playing is dominated by logic and clarity, and free of eccentricity. The articulation was so precise and clear that one could almost take a dictation from his performances. The other aspects of his interpretations were eloquence and lucidity with which he transferred his understanding of the form and construction of Beethoven’s scores. His piano playing reminds me a bit of the equally clear‑headed, slightly detached, precise, and technically flawless interpretations of past masters such as Robert Casadesus or Wilhelm Backhaus.
Despite his generally superb playing, in Vonsattel’s art I am missing one element, which I can only describe as “the warmth.” I missed that mostly in the slower movements, where the vocal character of the phrases and inflexibility of tempo, combined with the very clear, accurate sound production, might have contributed to the feeling of indifference.
However, what I found particularly compelling, perhaps even more so in the second recital (“Beethoven II”), was the energy, temperament and vigor which this pianist demonstrated in the opening “con brio” (i.e., fast) movements of Sonatas op.7 and op.22. Sheer virtuosity of the first movement of the Sonata in E‑flat (and how easily it was dispatched) could evoke enthusiasm of even the most discriminating listener.
My tad critical comments didn’t change the fact that I was listening to both recitals with keen interest and high regard for the pianistic skills, of which I have been aware for the last two decades. The difference in aesthetics didn’t diminish my respect and admiration for Vonsattel’s effort and ability to present one of the clearest and best‑played versions of the Beethoven complete cycle that we have heard in New York.
An added attraction in the presentation of this series, which should cause the audience’s gratitude, is the fact that all of the recitals are being streamed available for a period of 72 hours. The second of them, from Nov. 5th, is, as of this writing, is still available on YouTube. For the readers who would like to meet this compelling artist and performer as an educator, I have to strongly recommend his very attractively presented in a friendly, and easy-to-comprehend lecture on Beethoven.
The remaining dates of the Beethoven complete sonatas for the piano presented by the CMS at Rose Studio are:
Beethoven III: December 1 & 2, 2026
Beethoven IV: January 14 & 15, 2027
Beethoven V: January 26 & 27, 2027
Beethoven VI: March 1 & 2, 2027
Beethoven VII: March 11 & 12, 2027
Beethoven VIII: March 30, 2027 (at Alice Tully Hall)
Roman Markowicz
|